Tuesday, September 1, 2026

To be witnessed

To be witnessed, to be seen, to have your existence validated. To see yourself. To see others. To observe and be observed. To feel. 

Over the last 15 years I've found myself coming to this same idea about feeling seen by others, about how "being" is less of a property of oneself and it is more of a relationship to another. That to "be", requires the existence of another who you aren't. And through that witnessing one actually feels that they are real. 

Or less than an idea, it's more of a concept, that there exists a thought I want to think but somehow can't properly convey.  Descartes said "cogito, ergo sum", but that feels unsatisfying. In research done on solitaire confinement(page 98), "It appears that the sense of self, the ego and ego boundary phenomena are profoundly affected by the isolation". And I don't think it takes profound isolation for this to happen. 

And through this thought or feeling I felt the need to communicate: "I see you, I was you, here's a path.", both to myself and to others. 

My very first blog https://itadeufa.wordpress.com/ was created with this desire of showing a path to people who wanted to take part in science competitions but didn't know how and felt alone in this.  One of the first things I've ever wrote which encapsulates some of this:

> Espero que alguém um dia faça proveito das informações aqui contidas.

And this was a constant in my life. I've always wanted someone to one day be helped by my words.  I wanted to make people feel seen and helped and in the process feel seen as well. 

Because of this want to be seen,  I always enjoyed songs for their lyrics, for their storytelling. The lyrics made me feel seen. They helped me. They "felt" what I myself refused to feel. Lots of stories and books helped me as well.  When i see my pain in others, it allowed myself to feel my own pain and make it smaller. And in the process I could communicate my own pain to help others. For the most part I communicated how to handle it, with the pain itself being implied. Saying: "look here is a guide on how to prepare for this competition" , with the implied pain of not having a guide and having to figure out on my own. Or advice on how to keep going or deal with regret, with the implied pain that I have to deal with those, though at times making the pain more clear. 

Other times I've tried to communicate just the pain, often using music or poetry:


Ponto do infinito

 

Duas retas concorrentes

que se cruzam uma vez

Decidem jogar xadrêz

até que uma se rende

 

A outra mostra as estrelas

Na grande imensidão

Na esperança de vê-las

Juntas, dando se as mãos

 

Mas a sorte não foi essa

Que grande decepção

A vida fez esta peça

Sem rumo nem direção


Como duas paralelas

As duas retas se vão

Olhando pela janela

Sentadas no avião


Or when trying to communicate the feeling of going outside and looking at the sky and knowing that it's moving wrong and the moon is wrong, and there is nothing you can do about it: 

https://youtube.com/shorts/TlZokXcJsb8?is=dhhYsYM6uCPOC0BY 

However at some point there were some bad consequences to me for sharing information and trying to help people: https://ivan.fyi/blogging-past-and-not-blogging-rant.html  and I decided to leave in fear of sharing more things with others. 

But doing so removed a part of me I did not want to lose. Removed a part of me I miss. The part of me that would grab a laptop in an airport and start writing about the excitement of a trip mixed with the worries and stress, and share it with the world, and then many months later receive a message from someone saying that hearing me talk about having a broken heart helped motivate him to keep going. The part of me who tried to share both the paths I found as well as the thorns in the way, so that others could see their pain validated.


And although I've started and stopped blogging multiple times throughout the years, I wish to blog again. To write again. To share again.


To be a witness of life, to share the observations, to help and to be witnessed.

No comments:

Post a Comment

American culture when applying for jobs

 At MIT there was a class that every EECS student had to take and most people hated, 6-UAT. I like to call it learn to speak for software en...